Writers in the Storm

A blog about writing

storm moving across a field
December 20, 2024

COVER ME: a critical look at book covers

A critical look at book covers on Writers In the Storm.

by Rebecca Forster

Topping my list of things critical to a books success are: a well- crafted story, a great editor, an exciting blurb, and, above all, an exceptional cover. But covers, like books, are not created equal and they serve different masters.

Branding: 3 Types of Covers

Here are three types of book covers with a "branding purpose." You have likely seen all of them.

Corporate Branding

Harlequin is a great example of corporate branding. Graphic elements such as type font and size, logo placement, and central images are as prescribed as the writing guidelines. A mere glance at the covers and the reader’s mind registers some key book elements:

  • category romance
  • happy for now, or happily ever after ending
  • short novel
    and, above all...
  • published by Harlequin.

The author is secondary to the brand.

Genre/Series Branding

The Idiots Guide to (insert word) or Chicken Soup for the Soul are fabulous examples of this.  The graphic elements are set in stone, making it simple for the reader to identify the book as being part of the over-arching series. These elements tend to be colorful and bold, the titles self-explanatory and prominent.

Author Branding

John Grisham’s books use a clean, easily read font for his name. His name fills the top third of his covers. The titles are secondary and the images are pleasant but not genre explicit. Grisham is the reason you are picking this book up, period. Many big name authors use this formula, and some indie authors are harnessing the power of distinct author branding.

My Own Cover Journey

My Traditional Years

During my 25 years as a traditionally published author, I wrote for Harlequin, Penguin Putman, Kensington Books, Harper Collins, and other houses. My covers from Harlequin were indistinguishable from other Harlequin authors, as we noted above. At the time, Harlequin is focused on their own corporate brand. My single title covers went from basic to intricate only when my book sales warranted the extra expense of foils and raised fonts.

The Indie Challenge

I entered indie publishing with 20+ books in my inventory, due to all the rights that reverted to me from my previous publishers. I was not, however, free to use the covers that were previously created. My initial efforts to create covers by myself were childish, and did me no great service in terms of sales. But, now that there were no advances on the horizon, my own efforts were all I could afford.

Luckily, my fortunes changed.

I hired a great editor, PR person, and I went in search of a cover designer. I had some luck, but nothing that knocked my socks off. The truth is, a person with a graphic program is not necessarily a cover designer. I discovered that two of these designers were actually using templates. That was fine, but I wanted more.

I just couldn’t quite define what that ‘more’ was.

In-House Again

Forgotten Witness - Rebecca Forster

Over the years, graphic design programs become user-friendly and reasonably priced, so I committed to learning how to create compelling covers. There was a lot of trial and error. Sometimes I succeeded—spot color and stark graphics for The Witness Series have proven successful, with over 3 million books downloaded.

Before Her Eyes - Rebecca Forster

My favorite self-made cover is Before Her Eyes (the book is also a personal favorite.).  Both these efforts are evocative of the stories. 

I was not so successful with the Finn O’Brien Thrillers. I knew what I wanted those covers to look like, I did a decent job of interpreting my ideas, but something kept them from being compelling.

Enter a Master Cover Designer.

I befriended an author, Luke Romyn, online.  I loved his storytelling but I was enamored with his covers. When I asked who designed them, he said that he did. It seems Luke is a graphic artist turned author, and the reason I loved his covers was indefinable. It had to do with depth of color and composition. I was drawn to them, understanding the story before I read a word.

I wanted that feeling for the cover of my books.

He took my "acceptable" Finn O’Brien covers and turned them into spectacular ones. Suddenly, there was an electricity that crackled off my thriller covers. The fonts he chose turned my name and the titles into bold statements. The tilt of a letter or intrusion of a graphic element into the type gave the cover life.

I possess a good eye; Luke has an extraordinary one. Look at the difference between my covers (left) and his covers (right).

The Bottom Line

It is impossible to quantify the soul of a graphic artist. They bring something akin to umami to the design table. Their talent is deep and ethereal. They seem to know more about our stories than we do without ever having read the book. Whatever the magic is, I’m glad Luke has it and am honored that he has me covered. If you want to see what I mean, check out Luke’s books awesome covers.

If you want to shake up your book sales, take a look at your covers.

What do you look for in a book cover, and do you know what cover elements make YOU buy? Do you create your own book covers or hire someone else to do the job? If you use a designer, feel free to recommend them below!

* * * * * *

About Rebecca

Rebecca Forster started writing on a crazy dare and found her passion. Now a USA Today and Amazon best selling author, Forster is known for her legal thrillers and police procedurals. Over three million readers have enjoyed her Josie Bates thrillers in the Witness Series alone. With over 40 books to her name, Rebecca had a long career in traditional publishing before becoming an indie author. Her fast-paced tales of law and justice are known for deep characterization and never-see-it-coming endings.

In an effort to make her work as realistic as possible, Rebecca has graduated from the DEA and ATF Citizens academies, landed by tail hook and spent two days on the nuclear submarine U.S.S Nimitz, engaged in police ride-alongs, and continues to court watch whenever possi

Rebecca has taught at the acclaimed UCLA Writers Program and various colleges and universities. She is a sought-after speaker at bar and judges' associations as well as philanthropic groups and writing conferences. Rebecca is also a repeat speaker at the LA Times Festival of Books.

9th Witness - Rebecca Forster

Rebecca has just released The 9th Witness, the final book in her acclaimed Witness Series, Josie Bates Thrillers. Find all her books at any online bookstore or here: https://www.rebeccaforster.com/.

FacebookTwitterInstagramAmazon Author PageBookbub Author Page

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

26 comments on “COVER ME: a critical look at book covers”

  1. I just recovered (again) my Harlequin super romances. The first covers were OK, but dated. Found a great cover designer on 99 designs. Since I had five covers to be done, she cut the price to the bone, so I could afford them. I’m so happy with the result!

  2. As a self-publisher who can't afford a cover artist and is no graphic designer, I can relate to this. The trouble is, I can't tell you why I might prefer one cover over another, and I don't have enough knowledge to even decide which of several options I prefer... 🙁
    although I can immediately see the different vibe with your two new covers.

    1. If you can't afford custom book covers, look into premade book covers. They are not templates, unique designs are only sold once, but depending on genre vary from $40 to $200.
      A Google search will provide plenty of options 😉

  3. In two cover design competitions that I entered (I didn't win!)the winning covers were ones I would not pick up in a shop. To me they were bland, cartoony things.
    Another thing I find a turnoff are covers for romance with a man's torso with rippling muscles. Usually without a head.
    My own covers are designed by one of the designers at the publisher who publishes my books. I love them. They give a feel of the book.

  4. Love this, Rebecca! With my publishing, I use a range of covers from ones I've done myself to ones that we've hired. Deranged Doctor designs is one of my favorite designers. I've also loved working with artists to create custom artwork and then giving that to the designer to turn into a cover. The two can combine into something amazing. And they definitely make a difference in sales.

  5. Good examples of successful branding. I screwed up on mine, but in my defense, a lot had to do with publishers going out of business and leaving me to find new ones with their own ideas about how my books should look. I would have fared better if I had self-published. Hindsight makes this very clear.

  6. I designed my first three covers and like all of them (I heard a publisher say 'If the author doesn't like the cover, they won't push the book' - that resonated with me). For my fourth (published in October), however, I saw a picture from Deb Little, a professional photographer, and absolutely fell in love with it. We negotiated pricing and I ended up buying the rights to three of her photographs, which meant done deal for this trilogy. She also modified all of them to include the back cover at no extra charge.

  7. Nice essay! I wish I could afford any of it! If you write novels that are illegal in half the world's countries (sex anyone) you must expect little public interest.

  8. My first two books I put little effort into the cover. My mistake. I allowed the publisher to pick a cover. This is not going to happen with book 3. As a reader I want the cover to tell a story. It needs to grab my curiosity in some way. Daisy Jones and The Six is a great example. It grabbed my attention before I knew what it was about. That is powerful. A cover that can do that will sell your book. Thank you for the excellent info. I really appreciate it.

    1. Bryan, so right. I gave in a lot on covers when I was traditionally published. Hindsight is a wonderful thing and if only I knew then what I know now. And yes, Daisy Jones and the Six is a perfect example.

Tagged as:

Subscribe to WITS

Recent Posts

Search

WITS Team

Categories

Archives

Copyright © 2025 Writers In The Storm - All Rights Reserved