When the Second Draft Feels Like a Step Back
by Janice Hardy
You thought you were done—until you read your draft again.
The first time I finished a first draft, I celebrated with an entire box of chocolate. I’d completed a novel! All that stood between me and a polished manuscript I could start submitting to agents was one quick pass to clean things up. How hard could a second draft be, right?
I poured my heart and soul into that next draft, and followed all the advice I’d read about. I revised my manuscript into what I was sure was a solid book ready to go.
Then I read it again.
Yikes. My “brilliant plot” had holes you could drive a tank through. My “witty banter” made me cringe. My protagonist came across as whiny and inconsistent. That second draft was a disaster, and for a moment, I seriously wondered if I should ditch the whole thing and start over.
A messy second draft doesn’t mean you got it wrong—it means you’re actually seeing what you need to do to get it right.
That emotional high from finishing a draft is real—and well earned, ’cause this stuff is hard. But once the celebration is over and you read it again, the flaws jump out.
It’s not just disappointing, it feels like the whole book is falling apart and you wasted all that time writing junk. But here’s the truth: every writer goes through this. That drop from confidence to self-doubt is a normal part of the process. Your story isn’t broken, it’s just ready for the next stage of its journey (and so are you).
Why the Second Draft Feels Like Failure
A first draft is about getting the story down. It’s raw and instinctive, often written on the momentum of discovery. But the second draft? Ugh. That’s where the critical brain kicks in.
- You see the plot connections you missed.
- You notice the flat dialogue because you hadn’t figured out who those characters were yet.
- You realize your protagonist’s character arc doesn’t suit the great theme you added halfway through.
This shift from drafting to analysis can be brutal, especially when the manuscript doesn’t live up to your original vision. But don’t worry. You’re just seeing the opportunities to make it better. The things you couldn’t have noticed until that first draft was down and the story was out of your head.
The Good News? It Means You’re Growing
Feeling discouraged in your second draft usually means you’ve improved as a writer since you started the book.
You’ve learned new skills. You’ve strengthened a skill you once sucked at. The better your craft gets, the higher your standards get, and that’s a good thing. It shows where you’ve grown and how far you’ve come in just one draft.
Revisions Are Refinements
Think of your manuscript like a block of marble. That first draft is just carving out the rough shape of the idea and getting the story onto the page. You might even be the only one who can see the story lurking there.
But the second draft is when the real sculpting begins.
That’s where you smooth the rough spots and bring out the hidden beauty buried beneath the surface. You’ll chip away pieces you love, but you’ll be smart (and strong) enough to realize they don’t serve the story. You’ll leave chips and dust everywhere, and yes, sometimes it feels like you’re making it worse instead of better.
But this is when your story starts to emerge.
You’re making intentional choices instead of instinctual ones. Strengthening the story and ditching what doesn’t belong, and turning it into the book you imagined when you first sat down to write it.
Don’t Despair When It All Feels Hopeless
Facing a challenging revision is disheartening, and I’ve been there so, so many times. A rough second draft can feel overwhelming. Heck, I’ve had third and fourth drafts that tried to kill me, too (but that’s another post).
Instead of spiraling into self-doubt, take these steps:
1. Make a plan.
Read through your draft and take notes. Not just on what’s broken, but what feels off, underdeveloped, or unnecessary. Group your notes into categories like plot, character, pacing, dialogue, and description. Then break each category down into specific, actionable steps. A checklist gives you direction, keeps you from feeling lost, and lets you celebrate each win as you work through the list.
2. Focus on strengths.
It’s easy to obsess over what’s not working, but take time to note the scenes, characters, or lines that do work. These are your story’s anchors—the parts that already reflect your vision. Read them again and ask yourself why they’re strong. Is it the voice? The pacing? The emotional impact? Let those scenes set the bar for the rest of your draft and bring the weaker parts up to the same level. Not only does this give you something to strive for, it reminds you that the great stuff is already there.
3. Do one pass at a time.
Revision can feel overwhelming when you’re trying to fix everything at once. Instead, focus on one element per pass and ignore the rest until you’re ready for it. Maybe your first pass is just for structural fixes—tightening plot, removing or moving scenes. Once that’s done, shift to character development. Then pacing. Then dialogue. Layering your edits makes the work more manageable and helps you stay focused and consistent.
Looking at your second draft objectively allows you to see the cracks, the soft spots, and the pieces that need shoring up. This is where a rough draft starts becoming a real novel.
Even when you’re chipping away pieces, you’re revealing what matters most.
So keep going. You’ve already done the hard part—you finished a freaking novel. Celebrate that. Reward yourself and take pride in all the work you put into it. Now it’s just a matter of shaping what’s already there into the story you always knew it could be.
EXERCISE FOR YOU:
Take five minutes and list three things you love about your draft and three things you know you want to fix. Use that list as a starting point to prepare yourself to dive into revising that second draft.
A quick heads up! I’m talking more about revision during the Book Sales School Summit this Friday (June 13th).
My session covers how to approach revision in three layers (story, structure, and line edits) along with how to spot weak stakes, fix pacing through structure, and avoid common traps like editing too early (and more).The summit is FREE for a limited time, but there’s an option to buy it to rewatch it.
What’s the hardest emotional hurdle you face during revisions—and how do you work through it? Please share your story with us down in the comments!
* * * * * *
About Janice
Janice Hardy is the award-winning author and founder of the popular writing site Fiction University, where she helps writers improve their craft and navigate the crazy world of publishing. Not only does she write about writing, she teaches workshops across the country, and her blog has been recognized as a Top Writing Blog by Writer’s Digest. She also spins tales of adventure for both teens and adults, and firmly believes that doing terrible things to her characters makes them more interesting (in a good way). She loves talking with writers and readers, and encourages questions of all types—even the weird ones.
Find out more about writing at www.Fiction-University.com, or visit her author’s site at www.JaniceHardy.com. Subscribe to her newsletter to stay updated on future books, workshops, and events and receive her ebook, 25 Ways to Strengthen Your Writing Right Now, free.
Website | Facebook | Twitter | Pinterest | Goodreads | Amazon | Barnes & Noble | iTunes | Indie Bound
Top featured photo purchased from Depositphotos.
Leave a Reply
21 comments on “When the Second Draft Feels Like a Step Back”
Tagged as:
Subscribe to WITS
Recent Posts
- The New Rules of Book Publicity
- 2026 Is the Year Writers Stop Being Invisible
- What Developmental Editing Does for New Authors
- Lighten Your Creative Load: A New Year Invitation
- New Year, New Words: Writing Resolutions for 2026
Hi Janice,
This is great advice and flips the emotional drift from tossing out the whole story to fixing the idea that inspired one to write it in the first place. Thanks for this timely reminder!
Kris
Thanks Kris! Our hearts write the first draft, but our heads write the second 🙂 (darn, I wished I'd thought of that earlier for the post! LOL)
My 'second draft' is probably the fourth. I read and do edits of each chapter as I finish it, then my critique partners weigh in, and I make any adjustments they've caught that make sense to me. But yes, I still go through the entire manuscript once it's finished. I run it through SmartEdit which catches repeated words, redundancies, and a whole lot more.
SmartEdit sounds like a great tool, Terry. I'll have to check it out.
I get that 🙂 I'm a bit like that with my first drafts. I tend to write a rough draft or two before I consider it "first draft stable." I haven't seen SmartEdit before, so I'll have to go take a peek at it. Thanks!
The first time I run through my whole book, I usually have anxiety. In the last decade, I've realized that's overwhelm from some solid ADD. But when I am working on the drafts in Scrivener, I'm polishing each piece individually. Seeing it in a big fat Word draft is a huge "WHOA" for me.
The way I've solved that is I send it to my Kindle. For some reason, reading through it over there, and scribbling the notes down on paper, is way easier. Plus, I identify the holes and then go edit it in the particular chapter in Scrivener.
It has worked out much better for me than the way I used to do it. Which was freak out and print the document one chapter at a time anyway. LOLOL.
I love Scrivener, too, for similar reasons. The smaller files for scenes, the folders for chapters and acts, it just makes it so much easier to manage.
So cool! I've met a few folks who like to edit with Kindle that way. Seems like a great way to shift the brain to looking at it differently. Like printing it out or changing the font.
I'm so glad! LOL no freak outs for revisions 🙂 Small steps is the way to go.
I'm one of those weirdos (and proud of it!) who loves revision. It's a grand opportunity to develop the characters, the story arc and its throughline, insert foreshadowing, find details that fill out the narrative and make the setting and characters real and alive, etc. Revision first adds material that builds the story, then later distills it into a polished gem. Revision is a kind of privilege, even with - or actually, especially because of - the inherent challenges. Meeting the challenges makes one a better writer.
I've just begin the third draft of a historical novel that takes place in biblical Jerusalem, during the days of Jesus. It continues to be great fun, as I learn (through research) everything about those days and those people and their lives. My main character has come to life in ways I never expected.
I'm a big believer in giving the story room to grow in ways that are true to it and its characters, rather than to try to control its every movement. It reveals itself when I give it time to percolate.
Hi, Sally! I'm one of those weirdos too. I love being able to refine and build the story I wrote into the story I believe in.
I love Scrivener, too, for similar reasons. The smaller files for scenes, the folders for chapters and acts, it just makes it so much easier to manage.
So cool! I've met a few folks who like to edit with Kindle that way. Seems like a great way to shift the brain to looking at it differently. Like printing it out or changing the font.
I'm so glad! LOL no freak outs for revisions 🙂 Small steps is the way to go.
Oopsy, somehow it double posted. Can someone please delete that for me? Thanks!
More fellow weirdos! Love the idea that it's a privilege. We get to have all the fun.
Wow, that sounds like a lot of fun, and a ton of research to do. I can see how much revision would go into a novel like that as you learn new details and see how they affect the whole story.
Same. I like my outlines and plans, but I'll toss them out the window without fear if the story takes itself in another way.
My first completed novel-length manuscript was a mess and I knew it. But I have a massive determination gene (some call it bullheadedness), and I kept at revisions until I have no idea how many drafts I wrote. The end product was absolutely worth it and the process taught me tons about me and my writing. Now I face first drafts with a kind of glee, "let me at it so I can turn this misshapen rock into a gleaming diamond!"
Aren't they all? (grin) I think bullheadedness is a requirement for a successful author. I love that attitude! Totally resonates with me 🙂
Thanks for the reminders! I've been muddling through my second draft lately, and it's actually going better than any revisions I've done before, but there still is that struggle to feel successful.
My pleasure. Yay for better revisions! Like everything else in writing, it just takes practice. I can't promise they ever get easy (ugh), but you do get more productive with them, and that feeling changes from "I'll never make this work" to "how can I make this work?" You gain confidence and know you CAN do it, even when it is hard.
You're into your second draft now? You ARE successful! Don't let the rest of the world define "success" for you - that's your prerogative. Meeting the challenge of difficult writing is huge success - you may not be there right now, but you will be. Then you will not only feel success, you will know it.
Thanks Janice! Nice essay. I've written a lot of non fiction where revision (besides syntactic correction) is a matter of tightening up arguments around the central point. I've also self published a few (hopefully humorous) novels.
I've discovered the revision process is much more open ended in fiction. You don't want to leave anything gratuitous or superfluous in non fiction. By contrast, in fiction, superfluidity might be some part of the novel's texture.
If you write comedic sex romps that have an underlying story that isn't *about* sex, then all the sex scenes become gratuitous. But if you remove all the sex, it's no longer a sex romp 😭🙄😆
You're most welcome! Oh, absolutely. I've noticed that as well with my craft books. It's an entirely different process. It's like non-fic is intellectual and fiction is emotional.
LOL true 🙂 The trick is to make the sex about that underlying story and still have the fun romp! Which is a great example of how revisions can help improve a story.
I do much like what Terry Odell does. I’m constantly tweaking previous chapters and make additional run throughs after each chapter is critiqued in one of my groups. Once I’m reaching critical mass on one part of my story, I’ll give it a first run through ProWriting Aid.
This nevertheless doesn’t end my editing. Anytime I’m drawn back to a chapter, for whatever reason, I’ll usually find something else to change.
I do that as well (sans the software help). I submit two chapters a week to my crit groups, and I usually make the changes before the next group. That has it's pros and cons, though (grin). Sometimes they say things that send the story off where I never expected it too. That's where the heavier revision comes in later--I have to fix all those little readjustments to the story.