Writers in the Storm welcomes Shannon Donnelly back, as this month, she gives us some great tips on starting in the right spot.
When Do You Start The Story?
This is a good question—and maybe the hardest one to answer since there is no right answer.
Stories can start with dialogue, with action, with description. They can start with setup to help ground the reader, or with a little background, in the middle of things, or even after the story has finished.
The only two requirements are: catch the reader’s interest and start with the mood of the whole story. And even those rules can be broken if you’ve got the talent to pull off your intent.
But there are a few guidelines that can help, particularly when you’re struggling with that first page.
1. Start anywhere—and finish the story before you go back to fix the opening.
Many times, the right opening can come from getting to the end. By the end you know the mood of the book, you know the action, the characters (well, hopefully, you do). You have a lot better idea of how the book should open. That’s a great time to go back and fix the opening. This is a great help if you’re stuck working on the first chapters—stop messing with that and get on with the rest.
In Burn Baby Burn, my Urban Fantasy book, I always knew the opening scene. However, it wasn’t until I got to the end of the book that I realized a key character was missing—Josh’s mentor. She played a vital role at the end, which meant she had to be introduced at the beginning and woven into the story. If I’d had the “perfect” beginning that I didn’t dare touch, I would have been in trouble. But since I was ready to revise everything I could easily work this character into the story.
2. Start with dialogue.
Yes, you still need to get your readers into the scene, you need to introduce characters, and you need to move the story along. But a lot of times dialogue can be a great hook into a book. Dialogue immediately has your characters on the page and doing something. The caution here is that you can confuse the reader if you have too many characters talking. You can also bore the reader if the characters are only talking about the plot—remember, to interest the reader, your characters have to come alive on the page.
My Regency novella Silver Links begins: “Think carefully before you answer, Olivia, for your honesty or dishonesty now will determine the future of everything between us.”
That line is a great hook into a story because it gets the reader wondering and sets the tone (and character issues) for the entire story. The reader is left asking—why is her answer so important? who is talking to her? what did she do? what is she going to do? The story is about honesty in a marriage—about trust. And the reader knows this from the first line.
Now this story could have started with: Layton Carlisle, Lord Duncastle, stared at his wife and wondered if she would lie to him again.
That’s a good line. But it sets me into the hero’s point of view and the heroine has a lot more at stake in this first scene so I needed her viewpoint.
Or I could have started: Oliva stared across the room to her lord husband, wondering what had happened to the gentleman with the sweet smile who had walked with her along the wild shores of her native Devon, dodging the lapping white foam.
However, that’s a long sentence and doesn’t really hook anyone into the story—not even me. So, here, dialogue gives me the hook and the punch and the interest I need for the story. And it sets the tone. But it’s still not the only option.
3. Start with description.
If this is your strong point, use it. If not, go back to guideline two. Description’s advantage is that you can set up the world—you can use lyrical prose to set the mood and bring the reader into the story. This can be very powerful if you’re doing paranormal or historicals that need more details to help the reader see this “other” world. The caution here is that you don’t want to overdo the details—too much and you risk boring or overwhelming the reader.
In the opening for a Regency I’m currently working on, I needed mood, so I went with this opening: Darkling House seemed designed to intimidate—and was doing an excellent job of it. With a shiver, Ashlyn Somerleigh stared down the length of a private courtyard at the dark bulk piled into a rambling structure, four storey high, with a peaked roof and not so much as a glint of life in any window. Shadows clung to the uneven roof and wound around scattered chimneys. Gargoyles hunkered in the heights, at the end of the gutters, forever braced to spit streams of gathered rain. And rain was gathering.
In this story, with its Gothic tones, the house is an important character—so the description actually matters a lot. However, since this is a work-in-progress, I may yet get to the end of the story and find I want to revise this opening.
4. Start where the main character’s life changes forever.
A story is about a person whose life is out of balance—and what that person does to fix that imbalance. This can be a nudge that takes a person’s life out of what it used to be—it could be as simple as a letter that shows up, or it can be as dramatic as a half-demon baby showing up on the doorstep, as in Burn Baby Burn: Red horns faded to pink at the base where they joined up with pink-white baby skin, and Mackenzie Solomon knew trouble when she just about tripped over it.
Instead of this, I could have had the story start with Mackenzie’s ordinary life (which isn’t that ordinary). I could have started with her killing a demon (great action), but that wouldn’t give the main character a problem—it wouldn’t show the character breaking rules to save an innocent. And it would have delayed the reader getting to the good stuff.
The point of the story’s opening is to get the reader the good stuff as soon as possible—don’t make them wait (they may not stick around).
5. Cut the first chapter.
Go ahead. Try it. Put the book away for two weeks and then start reading at chapter two. Is it more interesting? Better scenes? Better action? This is hard, but it’s often the best choice.
When I was writing Paths of Desire, I had a prologue I loved. Adored. Would not let go of. Finally, I had to face the truth—the prologue was getting in the way of the story. It was getting between the reader and the story and confusing readers about what was the story.
I still have that prologue—I’ll email it to anyone who would like to read it and compare how Paths of Desire would be with that in place. And I may use it in another book someday—a book where it will fit better. But it did not belong in Paths of Desire.
So look at that first chapter—is it all back-story? Are you telling the main character’s entire life? Are you starting where the main character’s life changes forever? Look at the next chapter—can you cut it, too? Or even chapter three? A lot of times we, as writers, need to write fifty or a hundred pages to get into the story, but the reader needs to start after that point—when the story really takes off.
6. Start with conflict.
Every scene needs conflict. Even if that conflict is as simple as character A wants a glass of water and character B wants character A to leave. If the first scene in your book is all about nice people doing nice things, the reader is going to tune out and put the story down. We read to better understand ourselves and this world—that means we want to see other people with even more troubles than we have. Get the conflict going—and get it going over stuff that matters.
Conflict can be internal (Mackenzie Solomon in Burn Baby Burn knowing her job is to kill demons, but unwilling to kill a half-demon baby).
Conflict can be external (in A Compromising Situation, the heroine does not want to take a job as a governess that is going to end right away, but the hero needs her help now—he’s not going to take no for an answer).
Conflict can be with nature/environment/situation (in the example above with Darkling House, the heroine is both internally conflicted about going into such a house, and the house itself is being set up for a conflict).
Just get the conflict going on page one—and then you can better keep it going.
How do you decide where to start your story?
Shannon Donnelly’s Regency novellas are now available as from Cool Gus Publishing, as well as on Kindle, Nook, from Kobo and other eBook retailers. Her latest book Burn Baby Burn, is an Urban Fantasy, also out from Cool Gus Publishing, and she is now at work on another Regency romance.
Her writing has won numerous awards, including a RITA nomination for Best Regency, the Grand Prize in the "Minute Maid Sensational Romance Writer" contest, judged by Nora Roberts, RWA's Golden Heart, and others. Her writing has repeatedly earned 4½ Star Top Pick reviews from Romantic Times magazine, as well as praise from Booklist and other reviewers, who note: "simply superb"..."wonderfully uplifting"....and "beautifully written."
Her work has been on the top seller list of Amazon.com and includes Paths of Desire, a Historical Regency romance, of which Romantic Historical Lovers notes: “a story where in an actress meets an adventurer wouldn’t normally be at the top of my TBR pile; but I’ve read and enjoyed other books by this author and so I thought I’d give this one a go. I’m glad I did. I was hooked and pulled right into the world of the story from the very beginning…Highly recommended.”
She has also published young adult horror stories, is the author of several computer games, and now lives in New Mexico with two horses, two donkeys, two dogs, and the one love of her life. Shannon can be found online at sd-writer.com, facebook.com/sdwriter, and twitter/sdwriter.
BURN BABY BURN
Can a demon hunter raise a little bit of hell?
When a half-demon baby puts Mackenzie Solomon’s life—and her job as a demon hunter—on the line, she can’t turn her back on the half-pint of evil. But ‘Junior’ is actually part of a trap to turn Mackenzie’s partner, Josh, and his extraordinary charming skills to the dark uses of the ancient, fallen Grigori, the angels once assigned to be Watchers over humanity. Is she going to have to make a choice about the men in her life?
Can a charmer talk his way out of his destiny?
Josh learned months ago that the bad blood in his demon hunting partner brings out a part of he can’t control—including his desire for her. With a prophecy out on him, he’s more than a little worried some of those bad things should stay buried. But is Mackenzie really the start of something bad—or could she be everyone’s salvation.
Can a couple of humans move heaven and hell?
Mackenzie’s bosses at The Endowment—the place responsible for keeping the peace between heaven and hell—want her to bring in the baby demon and not for anything good. With the Endowment after her and demons to stop, Mackenzie knows she’s on her own.
But she’s going to have to learn to trust Josh—and to use what’s sparking between them. Because it's going to take the kind of love that bonds souls forever to keep the world from ending.
Copyright © 2023 Writers In The Storm - All Rights Reserved
It's funny, Shannon - I either nail this the first time, or struggle with it. It's different for each book. Jenny and I were talking about this a few weeks ago, and laughing about my second book - she kept making me start over. I went back to remember - I started that @#^$ book SIX times!
I'm glad now that I didn't kill her, because she was right. I finally got it right.
Thanks for the great post!
It is funny how every book is different. And sometimes you just don't know what is the right opening until you have the ending (that's why you have to keep writing).
But can we let the record show that we ADORE where that book starts now?? 🙂
Beginnings are not my strong suit. Like Laura, I either nail it or I struggle. Great post!
If you're nailing it even part of the time, I'd say that's not that much of a weakness 🙂
Wonderful post, as always, Shannon. When I started writing, it was easily 3 full chaps or more I had to cut. I've gotten better. I accept that I'm gonna put some stuff at the beginning that I need to write, but is perhaps not needed for the reader. (Notice I say "perhaps." LOL So I've not fully accepted those pages are not necessary.) In my 6th book, which I'm still editing, I only cut the first chapter. I see that as progress.
The great thing about digital books is you can now save that one chapter and post it later as free content -- nothing goes to waste!
OMG. Wonderful post Shannon. I usually start stories in the middle of some action that results in changes the character's world or dialogue but 1st chapters for me are usually rewritten more than any other chapter I write thereafter. And yes, I've gone back after the book is done as you've suggested and rewritten it again. 🙂 Thanks for this blog. Shar
Great post, Shannon!
I love your advice on just starting and then coming back to fix the beginning. I think this is especially true for a first draft. Often we don't know what kind of story we've got until we get it written down, and taking the plunge, as you've insinuated is the best way to find out.
I also agree with your advice on possibly starting it with a description. I love how "Uglies" starts something like, "The sky was cat-vomit pink." I've never forgotten that line and I always think of it, especially upon discovering it was the perfect way to introduce the MC's world for that book.
That's a great hook line. And you really need that hook into the story -- something that sets the tone for the entire book.
Great post Shannon! I especially like your point about only fixing it once you type "The End." That's been a hard lesson for me to learn, but hopefully it's sunk in and I won't waste so much effort in the future!
You learn so much from finishing a book -- it's amazing.
I thought I had this nailed with my latest mystery. Opened with dialogue, during which the protagonist is immediately shoved up a tree to have rocks thrown at him.
And the beta readers agree: instead of starting where his old life ends, start two scenes later, where his new life, though he doesn't realize it, begins.
Painful as it is to cut the scintillating dialogue, hard as it might be to weave two important minor characters back into the story for use later, I know they're right. Unfortunately, I'm one of those folks who still wants to write the final manuscript on the first draft.
Must. Kill. Darlings.
Keep the dialogue -- you may find a great place for it later (and isn't it nice to at least have the characters show up right away?).
Thanks for the eye-opener, Shannon! I write humour, and I would have said I generally start with dialogue, but your post prompted me to actually do a check of some stories. I was surprised to find I don't anymore! Maybe it's time I shake things up.
Sometimes dialogue works great -- but it's amazing how each story is different.
Great post, and wonderful suggestions as I prepare to start my next project!
Starts are always hard -- I'm about to begin a new one and I know it won't be as good on paper as it is in my head, but you have to put a flag down somewhere.
[...] Writers in the Storm welcomes Shannon Donnelly back, as this month, she gives us some great tips on starting in the right spot. by Shannon Donnelly When Do You Start The Story? This is a good quest... [...]
Great post on a critically important subject. Beginnings are one of the most difficult and most fun parts of a book to write. I like to surprise my heroines -- and my readers -- early on. The unexpected makes a good hook.
Shannon, that was great advice. I always have such a problem with my beginnings. I can't think of one I didn't have to change.
Reblogged this on Ella Quinn ~ Author.
Thank you for the reblog!
Enjoyed your post. I always try to get the tone of the first two or three chapters right before going on. Not necessarily the specific parts of writing, those I can edit in or out later, but If I can get the tone to work like I want, I set off in the right direction to begin with and I have an easier time figuring out just where to start the book.
I think I've tried everyone of those starts, including skipping chapter 1. Sometimes one will work sometimes you have to keep trying the other possibilities.
Yes, tone is so important. I think a lot of writers get stuck in the weeds and forget about that -- if it's a funny book, it needs to start funny, and if it's a dark book, it needs to start that way so that readers know what to expect. I hate it when a book changes on me.
Thanks for the post shannon great post.
[...] Read Shannon’s blog: http://writersinthestorm.wordpress.com/2013/01/07/when-do-you-start-the-story/ [...]
Reblogged this on Romancing the Soul and commented:
I am a new Follower of Writer's In the Storm - and I want to share this great post by author Shannon Donnelly.
[...] When Do You Start the Story? by Shannon Donnelly [...]
I didn't find the true beginning to my book, until I'd reworked it many times. Thank goodness, I didn't stick with the original beginning which began with a sunset. I take it, description is not my strong point!
[...] Stories can start with dialogue, with action, with description. They can start with setup to help ground the reader, or with a little background, in the middle of things, or even after the story has finished. The only two requirements are: catch the reader’s interest and start with the mood of the whole story. And even those rules can be broken if you’ve got the talent to pull off your intent. [...]
[...] When Do You Start The Story? [...]
I've read enough great books to know that I have to start with a sentence that begs the reader to read the next sentence to find out more. My first sentences usually contain some air of uncertainty or mystery around them. They leave the reader with a compelling question or either who, what or why?
a wow post...it was always confusing for me to decide on start...but i think now i have a way out and thanks to you shannon .... once i wrote a very short story..i was so confused about start that started it with "once upon a time " lol... here is a link for the post if you would like to read http://www.writerbabu.com/post/88/cadbury_in_blood/ over writerbabu.com
[…] When Do You Start the Story? by Shannon Donnelly on Writers In the Storm blog Breaking Down Story Structure: MORNING GLORY, […]