by Diana Stout, MFA, Ph.D.
When I received my first book rejection, I cried. (More on that rejection later.) Over the years, I've witnessed many writers who've cried, whined, or raged because of a rejection. Some even proclaimed they're going to quit writing. It's not an uncommon reaction to feel emotional when rejected.
But, take heart. All writers have been rejected at some point in their writing career. All of them. Even published writers get rejections.
The difference between a seasoned writer and a new writer is that the experienced writer knows a rejection doesn't signify the writing was bad. There are many reasons why a manuscript is rejected.
Here are 13 different scenarios, all of which I've heard uttered by editors, publishers, agents, and producers at workshops, conferences, and through my own rejections.
As you can see, most of these rejections have nothing to do with your writing. It has more to do with the editors' needs or idiosyncrasies.
Only two of the rejections above—#1 & #2—are about the writing and it's because the manuscript wasn't polished. The next two rejections are about not following directions. So, only 4 of the 13 rejection reasons have anything to do with the writing or manuscript itself.
In late 1985, I submitted my first book and eight months later got a rejection with signatory initials that told me the editor had dictated the message. She was a big-name editor. It wasn't the typical mimeographed rejection so many used back then.
After thanking me for the submission, telling me the book didn't fit the requirements of their American Romance line, she said, "It is too melodramatic, based on trite misunderstandings among the characters, as well as contrived circumstances."
I cried. Three days later, upon re-examination, I realized she'd done me a favor. She'd told me exactly why she had rejected it. Also, I noticed she had said nothing about the setting. She liked the setting! Of course, her liking it was my contrivance, but it worked. I used the setting in another story, which Avalon Books later published.
Today's typical rejection procedure is that if you haven't heard from them by a stated X number of months, consider the work rejected.
Did your rejection come with a comment or two on what is wrong or on how to improve it? Celebrate it! Any comment means the editor liked something about your work and wanted you to know it.
Did your rejection come with a message of submit again or we look forward to hearing from you again? It means they like your voice and your style of writing and want you to submit again! It's now a matter of finessing a match of a project to their audience.
Do not, however, rewrite a rejected manuscript and resubmit it unless you're asked to do so specifically.
Send the work out again—right away. If you've submitted it half a dozen times, however, and are still getting rejected, it might be time to re-read, rewrite or revise, and get some expert advice from an editor or writing coach.
Good luck on your submissions!
Every author has a rejection story. Please share yours in the comments!
* * * * * *
Dr. Diana Stout is a screenwriter, author, blogger, writing coach, and former university English professor of writing classes who loves helping writers. Her students have said, "She smiles when she talks about writing." An award-winning writer in multiple genres, she's been told that she's "a writer to watch." With her most recent publication of Buried Hearts: A Laurel Ridge Novella (#4), she was told by Wild Women Reviews that " the characters—all of them—jump right off the pages. They are so real, so well portrayed. You make it look easy."
Copyright © 2023 Writers In The Storm - All Rights Reserved